The turnaround after raising concerns was outstanding. The senior editor assigned to me meticulously reworked my manuscript, transforming it into a polished, authentic version that stayed true to my voice and vision. Securing a feature in Kirkus Reviews was an incredible bonus, adding significant credibility to my book. The steady climb in sales and the professional support in the later stages made the partnership worthwhile. The initial editing phase was rushed and disappointing—overlooked typos, awkward phrasing, and a lack of alignment with my voice caused unnecessary stress. Clearer communication and more attentive quality control during the early stages would prevent clients from feeling like they need to "panic" or micromanage the process.
NYPH’s unwavering commitment to artistic integrity. Their editors refined the flow of my poetry without sacrificing its raw emotion, and the minimalist cover design perfectly echoed the collection’s themes. The sold-out Brooklyn bookstore reading series they organized gave my work a platform that felt authentic and meaningful. Expanding outreach beyond local events. While the Brooklyn readings were incredible, offering virtual or multi-city opportunities could help poets connect with wider audiences without compromising their artistic vision.
The transformative editorial support and unexpected prestige. New York Publishing House refined my manuscript’s pacing while preserving its raw emotional core, designed a stunning, thematically perfect cover, and secured glowing reviews in Kirkus and Publishers Weekly—milestones I never imagined as a new author. Streamlining print release timelines. While communication was transparent during the slight delay, minimizing such hiccups would ensure a flawless rollout for future authors.
Their unmatched industry connections and hands-on guidance. The team expertly navigated every step—from refining query letters and matching me with the perfect agent to polishing my manuscript for submission. Their attention to detail and insider knowledge made the daunting traditional publishing process feel achievable. While their process was thorough, providing a clearer upfront timeline for each stage (e.g., agent matching, manuscript revisions) could help authors manage expectations and reduce anxiety during waiting periods.
The jaw-dropping, last-minute placement of my memoir in The New York Review of Books, which tripled sales and validated the project’s potential. Their ability to secure such a prestigious feature—despite early missteps—saved the partnership. Initial communication and creative alignment. The social media team used generic stock photos that clashed with my memoir’s tone, and I felt unheard during early feedback. Proactive collaboration and tailored visuals upfront would build trust faster.
Missed our agreed start date by a week. But they overdelivered: 5-star reviews flooded in, and Barnes & Noble picked up my book. No regrets. No such areas for improvement.
Thriller marketing felt generic. Gave feedback—they pivoted, booked me on true crime podcasts. Sold 500 copies in a month. Adaptability saved it. No such area for imorevements.